Ultra-Gape wrote:What's your own answer?
My main thought is that with current prices I'm going to have to be MUCH more selective, with cost definitely being a factor. I know this isn't 'cool' by this forum's standards but what I most look for in scenes is lots of hard and fast balls-deep single anal penetration, with the woman as into it as possible (ideally orgasming!) and definite bonus points for a well reddened ass from spanking

. I also like really like to see both pussy and ass gaped open from fucking and spread, but I won't buy a scene specifically for this over the former.
I'll add that I currently have an NRX subscription which is great value in the context of ticket prices to buy scenes.
Yes I am same, I prefer single anal penetration or DP as well, just nice fast and hard and intense asspounding, where girl is into it as well or even begs guys to go harder or when they say "don't stop" and guys speed up even more and with orgasm, it's nice!
I would say the following after watching the trailer:
Good/Great value
Specific Models (Usually 5-10 girls I prefer, although I look for new ones and new talent all the time, newcomers with great potential)
Intense scene (I generally prefer DP for intensity and just one girl because too many girls can be distracting or too many guys, 2-5 guys on 1 girl is usually ideal for me) DAP and TAP, physics wise, it can be harder to execute, although DAP is nice sometimes with TS and some situations.
Multiple Anal Creampies
Anal Creampies Cum Puddle
Multiple Big Loads in Mouth before Cum Swallow
Tongue piercings
Dirty Talk
Little details like Spitting in the Mouth, spitting in the asshole, sometimes unique asshole or prolapse
I also, like when something is unique about a girl, like asshole shape, very skinny, tattoos, piercings, really nasty, gigantic tits, bubble butt, really nice face.