POLL: Nicole Black vs Kristy Black vs Nicole Love

[dodonet1994]

I know we're currently having a tournament but I always wondered about this question. The three of them are legends and at the same time I saw them very similar so sort them (1 is the highest and 3 is the lowest) and let me hear your opinions and the reason for your choice .

[dap-addict]

How long is this poll open?


I have intentionally chosen the so far most voted for option it turns out: 1) Nicole Black 2) Nicole Love 3) Kristy Black
My reason is as fellows:
Nicole Black is a kult GIO girl, also she started straight-to-DAP in her very first porn scene.
Nicole Love came a long way from pretty timid Gonzo and ex-DDF work to DAP and than her recent post baby pause comeback. She's very consistant for years now!
Kristy Black for sure is a past GOAT and she also spots my favorite tattoo, but in past few years she's become a symbol of evergoing OF only tease. Her two AGO scenes in 2025 didnt change that impression. Ofc Sandra Soul or Nikki Hill are even worse with their OF only teasing, but here we have only Kristy Black to choose from. She's become a bad Europorn symbol to me, sorry to say!

[feltrough]

1) Nicole Black 2) Nicole Love 3) Kristy Black for me all that OF nonsense with Kristy put her on third spot

[Latinloverf1]

1) Kristy Black: In porn since 2015, with 242 scenes credited to PornBox/LegalPorno.
2) Nicole Black: In porn since 2017, with 188 scenes credited to PornBox/LegalPorno.
3) Nicole Love: In porn since 2016, with 144 scenes credited to PornBox/LegalPorno.

Kristy has the best body of the three (especially her ass), the most beautiful face (a killer smile), and the best sexual performance (it's a pleasure to watch her get devoured by multiple cocks). Regarding the OF issue, I'm a subscriber, so I support her decisions, but I hope she continues to do more gangbangs.

[maxalkire]

How long is this poll open?


I have intentionally chosen the so far most voted for option it turns out: 1) Nicole Black 2) Nicole Love 3) Kristy Black
My reason is as fellows:
Nicole Black is a kult GIO girl, also she started straight-to-DAP in her very first porn scene.
Nicole Love came a long way from pretty timid Gonzo and ex-DDF work to DAP and than her recent post baby pause comeback. She's very consistant for years now!
Kristy Black for sure is a past GOAT and she also spots my favorite tattoo, but in past few years she's become a symbol of evergoing OF only tease. Her two AGO scenes in 2025 didnt change that impression. Ofc Sandra Soul or Nikki Hill are even worse with their OF only teasing, but here we have only Kristy Black to choose from. She's become a bad Europorn symbol to me, sorry to say!

Based on my porn collection, I voted Nicole Black(78 scenes), Kristy Black(62 scenes) and Nicole Love(14 scenes), but totally respect your rationale. I have jerked off more often watching Nicole Black, so she wins. In defense of Kristy Black, she's taken tons of dicks up her ass in a nearly decade long porn career. If her fans now want to pay $12.99 per month to look at photos & videos of her awesome ass on OF, then I can't blame her. If she has over 78k followers on her OF account, then she is generating millions of Euros yearly without having to do much. If I was a woman and had her figure, I woud probably make the same move. She gets to control what she puts out to the public and makes way more than she would making a scene with AGO or AH/GIO. At least she did something like this once upon a time:

[dap-addict]

If she has over 78k followers on her OF account, then she is generating millions of Euros yearly without having to do much. If I was a woman and had her figure, I woud probably make the same move.

Well, since we are not women but consume their porn performances, we shouldn't reward Kristy Black's behavior. However, poll shows they really also can sell OF here!

[Latinloverf1]

How long is this poll open?


I have intentionally chosen the so far most voted for option it turns out: 1) Nicole Black 2) Nicole Love 3) Kristy Black
My reason is as fellows:
Nicole Black is a kult GIO girl, also she started straight-to-DAP in her very first porn scene.
Nicole Love came a long way from pretty timid Gonzo and ex-DDF work to DAP and than her recent post baby pause comeback. She's very consistant for years now!
Kristy Black for sure is a past GOAT and she also spots my favorite tattoo, but in past few years she's become a symbol of evergoing OF only tease. Her two AGO scenes in 2025 didnt change that impression. Ofc Sandra Soul or Nikki Hill are even worse with their OF only teasing, but here we have only Kristy Black to choose from. She's become a bad Europorn symbol to me, sorry to say!

Based on my porn collection, I voted Nicole Black(78 scenes), Kristy Black(62 scenes) and Nicole Love(14 scenes), but totally respect your rationale. I have jerked off more often watching Nicole Black, so she wins. In defense of Kristy Black, she's taken tons of dicks up her ass in a nearly decade long porn career. If her fans now want to pay $12.99 per month to look at photos & videos of her awesome ass on OF, then I can't blame her. If she has over 78k followers on her OF account, then she is generating millions of Euros yearly without having to do much. If I was a woman and had her figure, I woud probably make the same move. She gets to control what she puts out to the public and makes way more than she would making a scene with AGO or AH/GIO. At least she did something like this once upon a time:

I believe Kristy Black would be extremely happy if that 78K subscriber, figure you mentioned on her OF account, were true. She currently has 157K followers on X; it would be as if half of those followers were also subscribers to her OF. The truth is, few actresses remain in porn after 10 years of career, because porn producers and consumers usually always want "fresh meat" and end up forgetting about the veteran actresses. But they still have a good fan base that follows them and consumes what they produce, even if on their own. New actresses are welcome, but let's not forget the actresses from the golden age of Legal Porno, like the anal queen Kristy Black.

[dap-addict]

Yes, but all 3 actresses here are Golden age and in porn for 8-10years.

[Latinloverf1]

Yes, but all 3 actresses here are Golden age and in porn for 8-10years.

Yes, I know, I've already written the year each of them started in porn. All three deserve to be recognized for their careers.

[jjwhite1985]

If she has over 78k followers on her OF account, then she is generating millions of Euros yearly without having to do much. If I was a woman and had her figure, I woud probably make the same move.

Well, since we are not women but consume their porn performances, we shouldn't reward Kristy Black's behavior. However, poll shows they really also can sell OF here!

Most of those followers won't translate into subscriptions, but I'd guess she's easily clearing mid-5-figures a month in subs, plus all the ppv stuff if she does that (most do, just to add to the bs).

I don't see this poll as rewarding her for that though, she's shot a ton of hard scenes for LP going back nearly a decade. She's clearly one of the GOATs of LP in general, not just in this poll. I think if you were to ask people about the peak of LP, Kristy Black is one of the first names they would think of. But things change, life happens, people move on. We can either be bitter about that, or accept it and be thankful that we've got a collection of literally hundreds of her hardcore scenes.

FYI I went Kristy Black > Nicole Black > Nicole Love

[dap-addict]

FYI I went Kristy Black > Nicole Black > Nicole Love

Yep, I think this represents on-going popularity with LP fans best. Nicole Black had all this GIO over-exposure discussion a few years back, which didnt help her in the long run. Nicole Love was compared to Kristy and the Russian Nicole always more of an alt option mainly due to her large butterfly pussy lips.

My choice is different, but for me present day counts more I guess as well as DAP performance and personal discussions with these actresses count. I'm probabely not the average LP fan in this respect.

[dodonet1994]

Surprisingly nicole love got no love here or even in her best pornstar poll. Although i voted kristy > black > love but the girl has the best tits and pussy out of the 3 and she's cute af the ultimate brunette an east European latina mix kinda thing, and a mother as well apparently

[dap-addict]

girl has the best tits and pussy out of the 3 and she's cute af the ultimate brunette an east European latina mix kinda thing, and a mother as well apparently

Nicole Love is such a sweet and caring mom to her daughter!
But I understand thats not a category here unfortunately.

[dap-addict]

Nicole Love playing with her baby daughter in 2023:

Baby not shown ofc for safeguarding reasons. (private foto)

[xxxVIPERxxx]

I quite like Nicole Love, but when compared against LPAV heavyweight legends such as Nicole Black, and Kristy Black...it seems obvious that she would pale in comparison.

Has Nicole Love made many GIO/AGO scenes? Has she branched out and diversified in to other studios like Mina has, does she do all the extreme sex acts that fans here would want?

So, it seems like a moot outcome that Nicole Love would come in third.

[dap-addict]

Has Nicole Love made many GIO/AGO scenes?

What you dont know that?
A ton! She also started for AGO after her post baby break comeback:
https://pornbox.com/application/watch-page/1192637

[Latinloverf1]

In my opinion, actresses should be valued for their entire body of work and not just for their current moment. For all the exciting scenes she filmed in 2018, Kristy Black truly deserved to be chosen as Performance of the Year 2018. Source: viewtopic.php?f=96&t=92361&p=1400095#p1400095

[dap-addict]

For all the exciting scenes she filmed in 2018, Kristy Black truly deserved to be chosen as Performance of the Year 2018.

Thanks, yes, but this is a 2025 poll and not a 2018 poll.

Anyway, in terms of who wins Kristy isnt at all that much leading: It's now only 14 votes for Kristy vs. 13 votes for Nicole Black - vs. 3 votes only for Nicole Love.

[jjwhite1985]

Well Kristy last shot for LP a year ago, Nicole Black hasn't exactly been super active in the time since either - only two GIO scenes and one for AGO. Plus this poll isn't based on recent activity, it's based on the overall, recent and old. I think your disgust of OF is clouding your judgement of Kristy...

Would be interesting to see a head-to-head with just Kristy and Nicole Black for a more accurate gauge on how people see these two. There would probably still be some recency bias in favor of Nicole since she's had scenes release more recently, but I think Kristy would probably still edge it.

[dap-addict]

I think your disgust of OF is clouding your judgement of Kristy...

Maybe.
Anyway, while I ignore OF myself as consumer, in Kristy Blacks case there is something special in her almost daily social media PR actions showing her ass, often walking outside, to attract new OF subscribers. One sure cant say she wasnt working hard promoting her new business model.

[Latinloverf1]

My personal opinion on Kristy Black's OF: It's GREAT (of course, her gangbangs recorded at LP Studios are unforgettable and the pinnacle of porn). But the content presented and the treatment given to her fans/subscribers demonstrate how dedicated she is as a sex worker. And something BIG and NASTY, in which she will participate, will be announced soon.